EDITORIAL Gulf War casualties include health and truth
After more than five years of denials, Pentagon and Central
Intelligence Agency officials have begun to admit that "big numbers" of U.S.
soldiers who served in the Persian Gulf War were exposed to chemical toxins
that may be severely affecting the health of veterans and their families.
Prodded by pressure from veterans organizations and sympathetic
members of Congress, Department of Defense officials have revised estimates
four times in recent months of how many soldiers "probably" came into contact
with dangerous chemical substances. The nerve agent sarin was among dangerous
substances unleashed following the 1991 Allied destruction of Iraqi weapons
caches stored in the Khamisiyah bunker.
The latest estimate from the Department of Defense, based on CIA
calculations, speaks of more than 15,000 soldiers exposed during that single
attack of the 35-week-long Operation Desert Storm. This figure is dramatically
lower than than the 100,000 and more reports of a range of illnesses suffered
by veterans and their family members since the war ended.
The official disclosure of this information, though limited, is
important because the Pentagon has begun to contradict its own version of
reality, staggering slowly out of a web of denial about what really happened
during Operation Desert Storm. Official calculations of soldiers exposed to
nerve agents at Khamisiyah alone have jumped from the zero figure maintained
for years, to 400 in June, to 5,000 a few months later, to upwards of
15,000.
Both the Pentagon and the CIA, however, continue to refute claims
from two former CIA analysts, Patrick G. and Robin Eddington, that agency
officials attempted to cover up evidence of 60 incidents like the one at
Khamisiyah. The Eddingtons have resigned from the CIA and are writing a book
about what they allege the U.S. government knew about the risks of exposure.
The Pentagon's admission of the possibilities of exposure
contradicts previous statements from officials such as Dr. Stephen Joseph,
former assistant secretary of defense for health affairs. During his March 8,
1995, testimony before Congress, Joseph insisted "there is not pervasive
evidence of exposures, even after much scrutiny." He was echoing a June 23,
1994, Defense Department/Defense Science Board report stating, "There is no
evidence that either chemical or biological warfare was deployed at any level,
or that there was any exposure of U.S. service members to chemical or
biological warfare agents."
But documents obtained by the Gulf War Veterans of Georgia through
the Freedom of Information Act and published by Dennis Bernstein of Pacific
News Service in March 1995 suggest that Joseph and other top level officials
who repeated similar statements -- CIA Director John Deutch, for example, on
"60 Minutes" last year -- were either shut out of the Pentagon's information
loop or were not reporting the whole truth. Their ignorance or denial may have
put in jeopardy the well-being of thousands of Americans who served in the gulf
and their offspring.
A seven-day nuclear, biological and chemical log released to the
veterans' organization, for example, suggests that the Army knew from the start
that exposure was a high probability. The log chronicles on-the-ground
incidents of exposure from Scud missile attacks and from the shelling of an
arms storage complex. "Report detected GA/GB (chemical agents) and that hazard
is flowing down from factory/storage bombed in Iraq. Predictably, this has
become/is going to become a problem," one of the entries states. "Israeli
police confirmed nerve gas," another informs.
Despite these internal documents and news stories about veterans
experiencing everything from aching joints to the birth of children without
ears or with stumps for hands, Department of Defense officials continued to
insist that no proof of exposure existed. It was only in June of this year that
the Pentagon concurred that the Khamisiyah bunker contained shells with
chemical warheads.
It is highly probable that many of the chemical warheads in
question were made in the United States by government and private companies --
all of which could be held accountable for an Agent Orange-style settlement in
the case of proof of a direct link between the chemical agents to post-Gulf War
deaths and illnesses.
The Khamisiyah bunker explosion is not the only Gulf War skeleton
haunting veterans and Pentagon officials. Congressional reports claim thousands
of soldiers were forced to accept a series of potentially hazardous
vaccinations. At least one, an antibotulism vaccine, had never been approved by
the Food and Drug Administration. A December 1995 report from the Senate
Committee on Veterans Affairs said veterans, under threat of court martial,
were ordered not to discuss the vaccines with anyone, even physicians who might
treat future symptoms.
The Senate report described the safety of the botulism vaccine as
"unknown," and it insisted that another vaccine, against anthrax, an infectious
disease, be considered as "a potential cause for undiagnosed illnesses in
Persian Gulf military personnel."
It is unlikely that these disclosures would have come about were
it not for the efforts of persistent people like Paul Sullivan of the Gulf War
Veterans of Georgia and Joyce Riley of the American Gulf War Veterans
Association. They have for years lived by what Sullivan described as a
Jeffersonian belief that the price citizens must pay for democracy is "eternal
vigilance" of government policies.
They and other members of their organizations joined by a few
members of Congress have taken major strides to make deception -- rather than
truth -- the new casualty of war. Few Americans can claim comparable track
records. For the most part, the U.S. public and mainstream media companies
swallowed almost whole the military's version of reality during the Gulf
War.
Recent disclosures make clear how necessary it is to listen to
those who speak from outside the media mainstream. Gulf War veterans and their
families already face risks to their health and lives because the disclosure of
much of the truth about the war was delayed. As citizens, we owe it to Gulf War
babies born with deformities to take a cue from Jefferson and the Gulf War
veterans and exercise greater vigilance of our government's accounts of its
actions in the foreign policy arena.
National Catholic Reporter, November 15,
1996
|