Books
From legalism to love as the source of morality
THE CATHOLIC MORAL
TRADITION TODAY: A SYNTHESIS By Charles E. Curran Georgetown
University Press, 272 pages, $19.95
|
|
By GARY MacEOIN
For those who studied moral theology in a pre-Vatican II seminary,
this book explains not only how Catholic moral teaching has changed in 50 years
but why. Some of the changes will surprise some of us.
Moral theology in those days was almost exclusively a study of the
manuals of casuistry, an encyclopedia for the confessor to help him determine
the gravity of specific sinful acts. For Curran, its function is to
focus our lives on the fivefold Christian mysteries of creation, sin,
incarnation, redemption and resurrection destiny.
The Second Vatican Council was responsible for this, as for many
other changes. Catholic tradition had long stressed universalism and
essentialism. The nature of the individual human could be known by reflecting
on the sameness of humans all over the world, a reflection that enabled reason
to determine how individuals should act. Manuals of moral theology reflected
this essentialist and universalist approach. By deduction from general
principles, they determined the morality of specific acts.
What Vatican II did was to shift the emphasis from unchanging
principles to historical consciousness, thereby giving more importance to the
particular, the individual and the contingent, and also paying more attention
to human subjectivity. Induction replaces deduction. Instead of striving for
absolute certainty, we realize we only need reasonable probability for
action.
In the logic of this position, the ongoing task of the church is
to learn as well as teach moral truth. We must begin with moral
truth, Curran writes, which the hierarchical magisterium with the
special assistance of the Holy Spirit, along with all the Christian faithful,
including theologians, are striving to discover. Indeed, Curran insists,
the need for the hierarchical magisterium to learn moral truth seems
greater than its need to learn the truths of faith. The latter are based
on revelation; the former on reason and experience.
Until 1960, for example, official teaching was that spouses had to
have the intention of procreating in every marital act. Pius XII changed that
when he approved of the rhythm method. Similar changes have
occurred as regards usury, slavery, torture, human rights and religious
liberty.
Vatican II, with its stress on the church as the people of God,
moved the emphasis from legalism to love as the operative motive in moral
actions. Much of the current tension in the church results from the unequal
application of this principle. Church structures, Curran says, have not
changed.
The 1983 Code of Canon Law, in basic continuity with the 1917
code, still supports a juridical model of the churchs teaching
authority in an institutional model of the church in which too much power is
concentrated in the papacy. Until church structures and institutions change to
reflect the church as a community of religious and moral discourse with a
special role for the hierarchy, the existing tensions will persist and
grow.
Part of the problem, Curran says, is that the Catholic tradition
has seldom reflected on power, connecting it to roles and often calling it
authority. This suited the pyramidal concept of church that dominated up to the
time of the council. Protestant theologians often discussed power in the
light of human sinfulness, but the Catholic natural law tradition downplayed
and often underestimated the role of sin.
Instead, Catholics insisted on stability, harmony, rationality and
hierarchy and overlooked the reality of power in social and political
life. Power is taken seriously by the theologies that have emerged since
the council. Liberation theologies stress the need to empower the weak and
transform unjust and oppressive structures. Feminists and black theologians
similarly recognize the role of power.
The U.S. bishops Campaign for Human Development strongly
supports community organizations that empower poor and marginalized persons to
come together to change their situation and their relationship with the holders
of power in society. The radical extension of human power in our times makes it
essential to understand its potential for good or evil. Nuclear power is
sufficiently deadly to destroy entire continents, economic power has worldwide
effects and what happens on Wall Street has repercussions all over the
world, Curran writes.
Modern technology accepts no boundaries, but we still have a
moral responsibility for the use of power. Although human beings are superior
to animal and plant life, all of created reality and the environment and
ecosystems in which we live are not simply means to be used by human beings.
Creation and the environment have a value and meaning in themselves, and cannot
be totally subordinated to human beings.
This is not an easy book to read. Curran is a professional and is
conscious of the importance of every modifier in scientific discourse. But his
final summing up is simple. Both the church and each member need continual
conversion. More important than individual actions is the attitude, the
struggle for perfection, that ensures that love of God, love of neighbor
and love of self ultimately fit together.
Gary MacEoins e-mail address is
gmaceoin@cs.com
National Catholic Reporter, June 18,
1999
|