Latino, black scholars protest
exclusion
By PAMELA SCHAFFER
NCR Staff
When David J. OBrien, renowned U.S. Catholic historian, took
it upon himself to put together a conference sponsored by an organization of
Catholic intellectuals, he saw it as, well, a bit of a good deed.
The organization -- the Catholic Commission on Intellectual and
Cultural Affairs -- is 50 years old and somewhat moribund, he said,
bowed a bit, perhaps, under the weight of its mission. The commission strives
to provide a forum for Catholic intellectuals across disciplines in an era of
dwindling interest and support.
After conference notices went out in mid-September, though,
OBrien was brought up short, reminded with considerable force of the
vitality in intellectual quarters he had neglected to include on the program.
OBrien, who heads the commissions board of directors, said he is
apologetic.
Outrage is probably not too strong a word for feelings that
Hispanic and African-American theologians expressed over being left out. The
pain was all the greater, some said, when they noted the conference title:
The Future of Catholic Intellectual Life.
Diana Hayes, African-American professor at Georgetown University,
said she had noticed immediately the absence of Catholics of color
when she received an invitation to the conference in the mail.
She said she had written OBrien to point out that the
program suggested that only Caucasians could speak about Catholic
intellectual life. OBrien apologized by return mail, she said.
How can you talk about the future, wondered Orlando Espin,
theologian at the University of San Diego, and not include Latino and Latina
scholars, African-Americans and Asian Americans? We simply dont
exist for the conference organizers, he told NCR. There is
not a single reference to our intellectual life on the program.
Too often, he said, Hispanic Catholics are viewed as
objects suitable for academic study but undervalued as
subjects capable of making significant contributions to U.S.
Catholic intellectual life.
Roberto Goizueta, theology professor at Boston College, said the
conference, while not itself a major event, had become kind of a flash
point for what is in fact a much larger issue in the theological academy and in
the church. We dont want to pick on this particular symposium, he
said. This is just one example of something that has been an ongoing
issue for us.
The title hit us particularly, Goizueta said,
because for so long its been assumed that the intellectual life of
Catholics is the province of Europeans. To talk about Catholic intellectual
life without including other groups within the church whose intellectual life
has not been given their due historically is an important issue.
Sixto Garcia, president of the Academy of Catholic Hispanic
Theologians of the United States, said that Hispanic and African-American
theologians are often grudgingly accepted
but expected to confine
ourselves to our Hispanic issues. There is a very real kind of
intellectual bigotry that can best be described as an assumption that we do not
have the intellectual, cultural or genetic makeup to discuss thinkers such as
Martin Heidegger, Karl Rahner, Maurice Blondel and others, he said.
Several Latino scholars noted in interviews that, by some reports,
membership of the U.S. Catholic church is half Hispanic, or soon will be, and
that dozens of Hispanic Catholic scholars are active around the country.
OBrien, author of numerous books on Catholicism in the
United States, professor at the College of the Holy Cross in Worcester, Mass.,
and an expert in Catholic higher education, is truly sorry, he said, for what
he described as an unfortunate oversight.
This organization has not been terribly active in recent
years, he said. The conference evolved rather haphazardly, and
Im afraid I gave it a pretentious title. I should have been around long
enough to know how sensitive these matters are.
Noting that several women are included on the program,
OBrien said he had intended to be inclusive. But I should have been
thinking of the cultural distribution as well, he said. I ran the
program by a couple of people, but I take full responsibility. Im not
excusing myself.
The complaints, he said, directed to him via e-mail and letters,
are quite justifiable. Speakers for the Nov. 12-14 conference,
being held at the College of the Holy Cross, include Fr. J. Bryan Hehir, dean
of Harvard Divinity School; Jesuit Fr. Michael Buckley of Boston College; Fr.
James Heft, chancellor of the University of Dayton; Sr. Margaret Farley of Yale
University, president of the Catholic Theological Society of America; Sr. M.
Therese Moser of the University of San Francisco, president of the College
Theology Society; and Monika Hellwig, executive director of the Association of
Catholic Colleges and Universities.
There was absolutely no intention of excluding anyone,
said R. Scott Appleby, director of the Cushwa Center for the Study of American
Catholicism at the University of Notre Dame and interim executive director of
the commission sponsoring the conference. And of course, he added,
Hispanic theologians are leaders in the American Catholic intellectual
community. Theres no question about that. David and I both understand how
important Latino intellectual leadership is for today and for the future.
This was a good wake-up call, Appleby said. It
shouldnt have been needed, but there it is, from our Latino colleagues as
we think through the restructuring and revitalization of this Catholic
commission.
OBrien said he had invited representatives of Catholic
academic groups, centers for Catholic studies, foundations that support
Catholic scholarship and other groups with an eye to developing new initiatives
to sustain Catholic intellectual life. The goal of the conference,
he said, is to come up with a list of projects that might be undertaken. As a
result of the controversy, the need for inclusiveness would become part of the
public discussion, OBrien said.
Traditionally, Catholic intellectual life has been nourished
by religious orders, he said, institutions of men and women, and by
seminaries, which are less and less able to provide that institutional
support.
Fernando Segovia, professor at Vanderbilt Divinity School,
described the omission as an endemic problem, but no longer one
that Hispanic scholars will let pass. Its not unlike the
womens movement, he said. Once the numbers grow, you can flex
your muscles and be heard in a way you couldnt before.
National Catholic Reporter, November 5,
1999
|