School of the Americas reforms merely
cosmetic, critics say
By JAMES HODGE and LINDA
COOPER Special to the National Catholic Reporter
The U.S. Armys strategy to silence the critics of its
notorious Latin American training school has backfired and further galvanized
opponents who want the academy closed.
Last year Army Secretary Louis Caldera pledged to reform the
controversial School of the Americas after the House voted to cut its funding
and a Senate conference committee narrowly restored it.
Were not going to allow the Armys reputation to
be dragged through the mud every year, Caldera said. I dont
want to go through another fiscal year with this torture.
Yet, his reform plans -- to give the school a new
name, modify its curriculum and sweep it under the control of the defense
department -- barely passed the House May 18, despite intense lobbying by the
Pentagon, Defense Secretary William Cohen and Secretary of State Madeleine
Albright.
The close vote in the Republican-controlled House promises that
Congressional battles will continue over the school that has trained hundreds
of the worst human rights abusers in Latin American history. The proposals
still need Senate approval.
An analysis by the School of the Americas Watch shows that the
proposed changes are cosmetic, a charge that some Congressmen and even some
school supporters concede.
The changes amount to perfume on a toxic dump, little
more than a new coat of paint, said Rep. Joe Moakley of
Massachusetts, whose attempt to close the school failed on a 214-204 vote.
I was hoping Id be out of a job, said Fr. Roy
Bourgeois who has led a 10-year campaign to shut the schools doors.
But all theyre doing is putting a penicillin label on a bottle of
poison.
Bourgeois, a Maryknoll priest and former naval officer, added,
Their attempt to divide the movement has only energized it.
Demonstrations to close the school broke out May 24 in a dozen
cities, including Washington, Boston, New York, Chicago, St. Louis and
Philadelphia. At Fort Benning, Ga., where the school is headquartered, 11
persons were detained for a protest by Oberlin College students who entered the
base with a timeline of atrocities committed by graduates.
A protest in November, an annual event in memory of the six
Salvadoran Jesuits, their housekeeper and her daughter, slain in 1989 by SOA
graduates, is expected to draw even more than the 12,000 who showed up last
year, Bourgeois said. Thats because this December is the 20th anniversary
of the murders of four U.S. churchwomen who were raped and shot by Salvadoran
graduates of the school.
If, as expected, the Senate goes along with the House measure
contained in this years defense authorization bill, the school will be
renamed the Defense Institute for Hemispheric Security Cooperation. The new
name is an attempt to suggest the school is abandoning the role the Kennedy
administration assigned it in 1963 when Defense Secretary Robert McNamara
announced that Latin military leaders were responsible for internal security
rather than hemispheric defense. Internal security refers to controlling
dissent within borders of individual countries.
Among other proposed changes, the legislation creates an advisory
board appointed by the defense secretary, but it will not even be required to
provide an annual report specifically assessing graduates as is presently
required.
The legislation, which will supposedly broaden the pool of
candidates, authorizes the training of police and civilian personnel in
addition to military officers, but thats a practice already in place.
Similarly, the proposal calls for the institute to offer courses
in leadership development, counter-drug operations, peace support and disaster
relief. Records show, however, that these courses are already offered, although
taken by only a small percent of the enrolled officers, according to Carol
Richardson and Alison Snow of School of the Americas Watch.
The overwhelming majority of soldiers now take courses in commando
tactics, military intelligence, psychological operations and advance combat
techniques -- courses that will continue to be taught under the new guidelines.
It was the commando course that was taken by several of the Salvadoran
graduates cited for the killings of the Jesuits, their housekeeper and her
daughter.
The legislation also calls for the institute to include at least
eight hours of instruction in human rights, the rule of law, due process,
civilian control of the military and the role of the military in a democratic
society.
Again, the proposals represent no significant change. The current
policy mandates that officers be given eight hours of human rights instruction,
which critics say is woefully inadequate considering that the commando course
lasts 10 weeks.
In fact, the Armys strategy to deflect criticism of the
school, which has had three name changes, is nothing new.
After graduates returned to their countries and tortured political
opponents in the 1970s, Congress banned urban counterinsurgency courses. The
school cancelled the classes, then taught similar tactics under different
course names.
The latest attempt, Bourgeois says, is an insult not only to
the people of Latin America, but to the martyrs like the Jesuits and the
churchwomen, to the poor whove been victims of this school, and to people
in this country who are trying to work in solidarity with the poor of Latin
America.
National Catholic Reporter, June 2,
2000
|