column Special Report: Under sanctions, simple diseases turn
deadly
By MATTHEW HAY BROWN
The Hartford Courant Basra, Iraq
The cranky ring of the old telephone
startles Dr. Faris Abdul Abbas awake. He glances at his watch. Its just
past midnight, the dark beginning to a new day at Basra Maternity and
Pediatrics Hospital.
The chief resident picks up the receiver. A 30-year-old woman has
suffered a cervical tear during childbirth. Now she is in shock from loss of
blood. Abbas is wanted in the delivery room.
He is preparing to leave his cramped office when the phone rings
again. Four-year-old Nawris Khatan, a favorite of the hospital staff, has
arrived at the trauma center in cardiac arrest. A cherubic little girl whose
name is Arabic for seagull, Nawris is severely anemic. Her parents
have been scouring the hospitals and blood banks of Iraqs second-largest
city for more than a week in search of blood for her monthly transfusion. They
have had no success.
Woman and child both need type B-positive blood immediately.
Abbas dials the number for the hospital blood bank, but he is not
hopeful. With plastic blood bags scarce under U.N. sanctions, the hospital
canceled all elective surgery months ago. For all other procedures, blood --
when its available -- is rationed sparingly.
The hospital blood bank has just one unit of B-positive, barely
enough for one patient. Abbas will decide who will live and who will die.
The 33-year-old pediatrician walks the darkened hallway to the
trauma center. He will not tell Nawris young parents that he is giving
the blood to the woman, an otherwise healthy mother of three. Instead, he tells
them there is no blood, and asks them to pray with him. Fighting back tears, he
begs God to spare the child until morning, when some might become available.
Back in his office, Abbas lays his head on his desk and cries.
Dawn is still distant when Nawris dies.
It is very difficult to work in these disaster
conditions, Abbas says softly, as another hot morning breaks over Basra.
This is just one instance. There are many, many instances like it all the
time.
The U.N. embargo has devastated all of life in Iraq. But nowhere
is the deprivation more evident than in the once-modern health care system,
where sanctions deny doctors the medicine and equipment they need to save
patients dying of the curable diseases burgeoning amid the wreckage of war.
U.N. officials estimate more than 1 million Iraqis have died in the last decade
as a direct result of the sanctions.
The embargo is harvesting children. Before the Persian Gulf War,
when food was plentiful and clean water readily available, the greatest
pediatric health problem in Iraq was obesity. Now, with widespread food
shortages and contaminated drinking water, undernourished children are stalked
by cholera and typhoid. UNICEF blames the sanctions for the deaths of more than
500,000 Iraqi children under 5 since 1991.
Officials in the United States, the strongest supporter of the
sanctions, blame the suffering on Iraqi President Saddam Hussein. They say
Saddam can end the sanctions by allowing U.N. inspections to ensure Iraq is not
developing nuclear, chemical or biological weapons.
But the embargo does not appear to be affecting Saddam or his
friends, who have billions of dollars in hard currency, access to high-quality
health care and a history of indifference to the suffering of the people. The
regime stopped cooperating with weapons inspections in 1998. The United Nations
withdrew its inspectors; the regime says they will not be allowed to return.
It is the people who are being punished. UNICEF says thousands are
dying every month.
This is unacceptable in medicine, to have patients die
because of a shortage of drugs and supplies that are readily available
everywhere else, Abbas says. It is a crime against humanity.
Basra, wedged between Iran and Kuwait, bore the brunt of the gulf
war. Now it is bearing the brunt of the embargo. Sanctions have kept the city
from repairing sanitation facilities and power plants bombed during Operation
Desert Storm. Now the canals that made this port the Venice of the Middle East
bubble green with raw sewage. The public water supply is contaminated with
human waste. Electricity flickers off for hours every day, leaving precious
food and medicine to spoil in the desert heat. There are not enough trucks to
haul away the garbage that rots in the streets.
Dysentery and gastroenteritis are epidemic. Chronic malnutrition
leaves children more vulnerable to pneumonia, bronchitis and other infections.
Polio and meningitis are making comebacks. Cholera and typhoid are thriving.
Before 1991, these problems were out of our minds,
says Dr. Ali Faisal Jawad, president of Basra Maternity and Pediatrics
Hospital. We have had to go back to the textbooks to learn how we should
treat them.
Jawads 320-bed hospital, the largest childrens medical
facility in southern Iraq, was among the best equipped in the country when it
opened in 1986. It had CT scan and ultrasound machines, incubators to nurture
premature babies and centrifuges to separate blood parts.
Over the years, much of the equipment has worn out, and spare
parts are unavailable. The hospitals emergency generator, in constant use
since the gulf war, can power only the operating room and the trauma center.
Without consistent electricity to run air conditioning or transfer systems in
other parts of the hospital, windows are left open. Mothers brush flies from
sick children lying two and three to a threadbare mattress on rusting iron
beds. The halls reek of the gasoline with which orderlies clean the floors --
it is the cheapest solvent in this oil-rich, food-and-medicine-poor nation.
Doctors here, many of whom have studied in Britain or the United
States, earn the equivalent of $4 a month. They share worn photocopies of
decades-old textbooks. They have little access to current research and no
access to the Internet.
Nurses earn less than doctors. Many have abandoned the profession,
leaving mothers and grandmothers to care for their sick children, administering
medicines and watching for changes.
The hospital needs scalpels and clamps for surgery, antibiotics
for infections and cytotoxins for chemotherapy. There is not enough specialized
formula to treat underweight babies. Syringes and surgical gloves are washed
and reused.
I do not think Americans would accept this for their
children, Jawad says. What is the difference between a sick
American child and a sick Iraqi child?
Visitors entering the hospital must step over a crude graffito.
Down USA, someone has painted in sickly yellow across the
flagstones of the courtyard.
The mothers line up in the main hallway of the pediatrics wing,
cradling their underweight children in the folds of their traditional black
robes as they wait for the attention of Dr. Hussein Mohammed.
Marium Talib cries in dry rasps as she hangs limply across her
mothers arms. At 6 months, she weighs 10 pounds, little more than half
her healthy weight. The skin around her eyes is brown and scaly; her arms and
legs and belly are swollen. A needle protrudes from her head, the only place
doctors could find a vein large enough to take nourishment.
Her mother, 21-year-old Sajida Naim, explains that the family
lives in the al-Moufakia Flats, a notoriously squalid housing development that
has no drinking water. The water the family draws from a neighborhood nearby is
contaminated with sewage. Marium now suffers from gastroenteritis. Mohammed
says the hospital is giving the baby medicine to clear up her diarrhea and
protein to improve her weight, but he expects the problem to recur when she
returns home and resumes drinking the water.
It may be too late to help Aleah Mohammed. The 1-year-old, who is
no relation to her pediatrician, weighs less than 15 pounds and has stopped
feeding. Weakened by gastroenteritis, she has developed a bronchitis that is
not responding to the simple antibiotics Mohammed has prescribed.
The future is even bleaker for 11-month-old Abbas Abed al-Hussein.
The brown skin of his face has turned a pale yellow, and his dark hair has
taken on a reddish tint. His swollen arms and legs stick out from his body.
Abbas is one several babies at the hospital with kala azar, a
disease transmitted by flies now flourishing because sanctions prevent Iraq
from importing an effective insecticide. The hospital does not have the drug to
treat kala azar or the separated blood parts to make treatment effective.
Mohammed expects little Abbas to die within days.
This is not a difficult disease, he says. But
under sanctions, there is nothing we can do.
Amid such conditions, more than one in eight children in southern
and central Iraq dies before reaching his or her fifth birthday.
Before the gulf war, Iraq boasted a free public health care system
that was among the most advanced in the Arab world.
This was a well-developed system, a well-funded system, and
there was a high level of skill among Iraqi specialists, says Richard
Garfield, a Columbia University epidemiologist who studies public health under
sanctions. It was never the healthiest place in the world, but medical
care standards probably were not that far from Western Europe, which made it
look less like a Third-World country.
Under the embargo, Iraqi hospitals now are limited to the
equipment, medicine and supplies that may be purchased through a U.N.-monitored
oil-for-food exchange. The Security Council blocks orders that could also have
military uses.
In 1989, the last full year before Iraq invaded Kuwait, the
Ministry of Health spent $500 million on medicines and medical supplies for the
nations public hospitals.
In the four years since the oil-for-food program began, the
committee has allowed Iraq to import $980.4 million in health-related goods and
is holding requests for $189 million more. The committee has held up orders for
heart and lung machines, syringes and thermometers, ambulances and refrigerated
trucks.
The United States, which leads the 15 council members in placing
holds on contracts, has drawn criticism for undermining
humanitarian aid to Iraq.
The United Nations has always been on the side of the
vulnerable and the weak, and has always sought to relieve suffering, yet here
we are accused of causing suffering to an entire population, U.N.
Secretary-General Kofi Annan said during a Security Council session in March.
We are in danger of losing the argument, or the propaganda war -- if we
havent already lost it -- about who is responsible for this situation in
Iraq -- President Saddam Hussein or the United Nations.
U.S. officials defend the holds as necessary to ensure that Iraq
is not obtaining military equipment. They accuse the regime of hoarding
medicine and equipment to increase the suffering of the people in order to gain
support for lifting the sanctions without dismantling its weapons programs.
There is enough food and enough medicine to care for and
meet the needs of the Iraqi people, National Security Council spokesman
P.J. Crowley says. It is a manipulation by Saddam, using the suffering of
the Iraqi people that he could solve if he wanted to. ... We care more about
the Iraqi people than he does.
U.N. officials say they have not seen credible evidence that the
regime is withholding humanitarian goods. They say an exodus of experienced
managers and the deterioration of storage and transportation systems --
themselves effects of the sanctions -- sometimes slow distribution.
I think the Iraqis want to be helpful and cooperative,
says Tun Myat, the U.N. coordinator for humanitarian aid to Iraq. At the
higher levels I have met with people who are clearly very sincere in saying
that they want to be cooperative and collaborative and which they try to be
within the limits of their own constraints.
The State Department has done a very good job at figuring
out what images and sound bites will work to demonize the leaders of Iraq, but
it doesnt do very much justice to whats actually happening,
says Garfield, the Columbia epidemiologist. It may play in Peoria, but it
doesnt help fix the situation in Iraq.
The large stainless-steel box in the morgue at Basra Maternity and
Pediatrics Hospital is called a refrigerator, but without power, it keeps no
cooler than room temperature, which has risen to more than 100 degrees. The
stench of decay fills the dusty, tiled room.
Dr. Abed al-Kareem Hussein opens the doors and pulls out the
trays. Cardboard boxes made to ship packets of cereal and rolls of aluminum
foil now hold the bodies of babies.
This is where the hospital keeps the corpses of children whose
parents are unable to pay the $3 required for burial. The hospital will keep
each for a few weeks before burying them in a paupers field.
Hussein has counted 13 tiny corpses when an orderly arrives with
another box. This one is marked Tiffany Milk Biscuits. Inside is
the body of a newborn who died after delivery, the fourth death in the hospital
today.
The cause? Hussein, who was not the attending physician, shrugs.
Sanctions.
This story, the second part of a four-part series, first
appeared in the Hartford Courant on Oct. 23. It is reprinted here with
permission. The full series can be found at www.ctnow.com
National Catholic Reporter, November 10,
2000
|