|
Movies Morality Play
By ROBERT E. LAUDER
In Ingmar Bergmans and Liv
Ullmanns new film Faithless (he wrote the script, she did the
filming), a relationship between a man and a woman is described as
friendship in damnation. While this phrase would fit male-female
relationships in many Bergman films and is exceptionally apt in
Faithless, it certainly does not describe the professional
relationship between Bergman, the Swedish author and director, and Ullmann, the
Norwegian actress turned director.
Though Bergman and Ullmann disagree on important subjects -- God,
love, death, art -- their artistic collaboration has contributed to more
outstanding films than that of any other two artists in the history of movies,
including Persona (1966), Cries and Whispers (1973),
Scenes from a Marriage (1973), and Private Confessions
(1997). Faithless may be another Bergman and Ullmann
masterpiece.
In John Lahrs book, Show and Tell: New Yorker
Profiles, Ullmann says of Bergman: He is connected to his creativity,
but not necessarily to the world. The statement can serve as a succinct
characterization of one of Bergmans predominant cinematic preoccupations.
Most of the films he wrote and directed, from The Seventh Seal and
The Magician in the 1950s, through Fanny and Alexander
and After the Rehearsal in the 1980s, reveal his intense interest,
if not obsession, with the artists creative role in society. Almost every
Bergman film has an artist as an important character, frequently serving as an
alter ego for Ingmar. In Faithless, the artistic alter ego is named
Bergman. When Ullmann asked Ingmar Bergman why he gave the character that name,
he replied that he couldnt think of any other.
Faithless may be Bergmans most introspective
script. The plot, if the film can be said to have one, springs from an incident
that occurred in Bergmans life years ago and disturbed him for a long
time. Though he tried to write about it for years, he could not. Perhaps in
finally writing the script, he is seeking not only an emotional catharsis, but
also a spiritual cleansing.
In Faithless, a famous stage and film director named
Bergman (Erland Josephson), now elderly, looks back on a relationship he had
with a married actress who has died. Josephsons Bergman looks at the past
through the eyes of the actress, Marianne (Lena Endra), whom he has called from
his memory to act as his muse and perhaps as his accuser. Here we have an
artist, the director, allowing another artist, the actress, to recall and
interpret his memories for him -- something like what Ingmar Bergman has done
in choosing Ullmann to direct his film.
Revealed in flashbacks, Mariannes memories are terribly
painful. She tells of her happy marriage to a concert conductor, Markus (Thomas
Hanzon), of their 9-year-old daughter, Isabelle (Michelle Gylemo), and of a
long love affair she had with David (Krister Henriksonn), who is
Josephsons Bergman at a younger age. The affair is entered into casually,
but its repercussions seem infinite, its fallout endless as people are deeply
wounded and lives are destroyed.
Once preoccupied with the silence of God, in Faithless
Bergman provides no space for God. His cinematic alter ego lives alone on an
island, recalling past sins but achieving no absolution, not even forgiveness
from himself. Though free of God, he is certainly not free of guilt.
The daughter Isabelles presence in the story is particularly
disturbing because, rather than suggesting some hope for the future, it
suggests the opposite. She is not only the physical offspring of Marianne and
Markus, but the psychological and spiritual offspring of the films
faithless adults. She will inherit the hell created by her elders.
Faithless is almost a gloss on the Old Testament adage that the
sins of the parents will be visited on the children.
Part of Ingmar Bergmans genius throughout his film career
has been to probe deeply into his own psyche, creating films that are deeply
personal but not private. The story of Faithless could have been
filmed in such a way that it might seem an exercise in narcissism. Ullmann must
be given credit that this did not happen. She took Bergmans script and
was in charge of everything else related to getting Faithless to
the screen, with no involvement from Bergman.
With each of the four feature films she has directed, Ullmann has
grown in her mastery of moviemaking. Critical reaction to Faithless
suggests that Ullmann has joined a special pantheon of European directors whose
films are a marvelous mix of metaphysics and mystery: Bergman, Robert Bresson,
Luis Buñuel, Federico Fellini, Krzysztof Kieslowski. Ullmann has
beautifully filmed those frightening monosyllables: to be, to live, to love, to
pray, to die.
Commenting on Faithless, Ullmann has said, To
live in a state of unfaithfulness at the turn of the millennium is simply a way
of life that more and more people choose to live, and traditional moral
dictates disappear.
As the director of this film, I believe the light in
the story is that we can forget the hours that were full of suffering. What we
must never forget is what they have taught us.
Ullmann has stated her belief that God is within us. If present in
the characters of Faithless, God must be crying. Yet with some kind
of movie magic, Ullmann has taken a story in which no one responds to grace, in
which there is not even a hint of redemption, and without being either pedantic
or preachy, she has turned it into a cinematic morality play. As Ullmann said,
Watching the film you may start thinking: I will think about my
choices -- who do they involve? How many will have that reaction
to the film I can only guess. I do know that this priest did.
Fr. Robert Lauder is professor of philosophy at St. Johns
University, Jamaica, N.Y. His e-mail address is
lauderr@stjohns.edu
National Catholic Reporter, March 2,
2001
|
|