Paper cuts in major dioceses have some editors
worried
By PATRICK ONEILL
When the World Trade Center towers crumbled to the ground on Sept.
11, it was perhaps the biggest news story ever generated in New York City. The
lives of millions of people, many of them Catholics, were touched directly by
the tragedy.
Yet, Catholics in the New York archdiocese had to wait three weeks
before they were able to read news coverage of Sept. 11 in their archdiocesan
newspaper. Thats because a week before Sept. 11, the newspaper,
Catholic New York, had cut its publication cycle from weekly to
monthly.
The cost-saving initiative, mandated by Cardinal Edward Egan,
meant that many Catholics living in 10 counties in the New York metropolitan
area had to wait until October for Catholic-specific coverage of Sept. 11.
In the Chicago archdiocese, The Catholic New World recently
went from weekly to biweekly, a change that will save the archdiocese a bundle
on mailing costs. The impact of the change is ameliorated by the fact that both
the size of the paper and the circulation were increased substantially, said
editor and general manager Thomas Sheridan.
Leaders in the Catholic press say such changes in two of the
nations three largest archdioceses could have serious negative
consequences for the churchs effort to get its message across. New York
and Chicago have about 2.3 million Catholics each. Los Angeles, with 4 million
Catholics, is the largest U.S. archdiocese.
Under its new format, Catholic New York publishes a monthly
issue that is mailed incrementally to approximately 135,000 homes.
Approximately 35,000 issues are mailed each week, but the editorial content
remains the same over the four weekly issues. Only advertising may vary. The
change resulted in Catholic New Yorks staff being cut from 34 to
14 full-time employees.
Sept. 11 happened on the second week of the cycle, and we
reluctantly and unfortunately had to just stand by and wait until the first
edition of October before we were able to put anything into the paper,
said Art McKenna, general manager and cofounder of Catholic New York,
which is in its 20th year of publication.
Despite great disappointment for McKenna and his staff,
Catholic New Yorks hands were tied. The archdiocese is in the
midst of trying to erase a $20 million annual operating deficit.
There has been so much of a spiritual and introspective
nature that has come out of the World Trade Center tragedy, McKenna said.
That is absolutely the kind of material that a Catholic newspaper is
exceptionally well-suited to handling. It is one of the most obvious
limitations of a once-a-month cycle. Our challenge is to make the best of what
weve got. Weve gone past the point of lamentation and lying in the
fetal position. You dont cover much ground in that position, but surely
our readers obviously are among the most loyal people in the world.
While Catholic New York didnt publish, two
neighboring dioceses, Brooklyn-Queens and Rockville Centre, with weekly
newspapers, were able to quickly get news of Sept. 11 into the hands of their
own Catholic readers.
A tremor
Liz OConnor, who has been associate publisher and editor of
Rockville Centres publication, The Long Island Catholic, since
1993, said the news of Catholic New Yorks cutback sent a
tremor in some of the Catholic press. I think people in the
Catholic press were distressed, she said.
OConnor said editors are worried that other bishops might
follow Egans lead.
I think readers read newspapers out of habit,
OConnor said. Our readers look for it. Once you break that rhythm
you may lose readership.
I think its unfortunate that they have gone to less
frequent publication, and I would be very unhappy should our bishop make that
decision, but I would also be somewhat surprised. I dont expect
it.
While Sheridan says he can still deliver a quality product to his
Chicago readers 26 times a year, he doesnt believe he could do it if he
only published 12 times a year.
I couldnt do it with a monthly, he said. I
think that would be, for us, foolish. Theres a very important clause in
that sentence, for us. I dont want to be accused of saying
what Catholic New York has done is foolish. I think theyre doing
the best they can under the circumstances.
Most editors interviewed for this story echoed the opinion that
the Catholic press offers its readers information they wont find anywhere
else. A longtime Chicago Sun-Times editor, Sheridan says Chicagos
local secular press does a good job of reporting Catholic news, but they often
highlight the negative.
A diocesan newspaper exists to tell the stories of the
faithful Catholics within that archdiocese, or that diocese, in an effort to be
affirming, informational, evangelistic, certainly all of that, he said.
Im not out there competing with the dailies who can do some things
better than I can because theyve got bigger staffs, but they cant
cover the church like I can. They can cover elements of it, and they can also
highlight the negatives. Im not going to highlight negatives.
In August, Owen McGovern, executive director of the Long
Island-based Catholic Press Association, published a column in The Catholic
Journalist opposing publication cutbacks for the Catholic press.
In many cases, the Catholic newspaper is the only Catholic
publication that comes into the home, he wrote. It is the only
contact that many Catholics have with the church on the national and
international level. It is also the primary means of communication that the
bishop has at his disposal to communicate with members of his diocese.
That can be crucial at times when secular press coverage of
church issues is filled with inaccuracies or misleading information. The bishop
must be able to respond and, in some cases, defend church actions and policies
in a timely manner. And, most importantly, parishioners want to hear both bad
news and good news from the church because it is considered the voice of
credibility and truth.
While secular publications may strive to publish accurate
information on church-related issues, it is extremely dangerous to allow the
secular press to be the only voice to reach the people on a regular
basis.
A proponent of weekly publication for diocesan newspapers,
McGovern says he doesnt see a trend toward reducing publication cycles
despite the decisions in New York and Chicago.
Bishops dont follow other bishops, he said.
Most of the time they do what they feel they need to do for their
diocese.
While he has seen cutbacks, McGovern is also seeing dioceses that
are dramatically increasing circulation, and in the case of the archdiocese of
San Francisco and the diocese of Anchorage, Alaska, papers have recently been
started.
Circulation increases
Overall, circulation numbers for the approximately 180 Catholic
newspapers is at an all-time high, McGovern said.
McGovern likens the Catholic press to a merry-go-round. One
paper goes up in circulation or down in circulation or up in frequency or down
in frequency, then another does the opposite, he said, like a
carousel going up and down. Its really not a trend in any single
direction.
McGovern said the onus is on the individual publications to show
bishops how important -- and profitable --a paper can be. Improving the
financial stability and quality of a paper might result in a bishop increasing
publication frequency or increasing circulation, he said. Cardinals and bishops
come and go, and while one prelate might introduce cuts, a new bishop may come
in and change everything.
Its basically what the bishop wants for his
communications, McGovern said. How can one bishop say, We
cant afford a program or we cant sell it to the priests, and
he retires and a new bishop comes in and within a short time he says, I
want everybody to get the paper and it happens?
In New York, McKenna hopes for just such a change in the
archdioceses economic viability.
We felt that the weekly edition of Catholic New York
was an exceptionally good example of Catholic diocesan journalism, and we still
think that the monthly is an exceptional example of good Catholic journalism,
but theyre not the same, he said. Theyre not the same
obviously, yet we are all compelled to face a reality and we would hope -- and
this is a personal hope -- we would hope that the circumstances that caused
this to be required may at some point be relieved in the future, and we will be
able to return to a more frequent schedule.
In October 1995, shortly after he arrived in the Raleigh, N.C,
diocese as editor of the NC Catholic, John Strange saw his papers
publication schedule cut from 36 issues to 26. The dimensions of the paper were
also reduced to save on the cost of newsprint. The NC Catholic is mailed
directly to about 55,000 Catholic homes at no direct cost to registered
parishioners.
Initially, Strange said he was worried that less frequent
publication would reduce the papers status among readers. I was
worried that we wouldnt be as relevant, as important to the
parishes, he said.
His fears were not realized. Letters to the editor continued
to come in. Requests for coverage did not abate. We continued to be a
voice.
Unlike Catholic New York, Strange is permitted to publish a
special issue if warranted. On Sept. 11, the paper was just being put together,
so Strange was able to switch gears and deliver full coverage of the events
surrounding the terrorist attacks, but he said he would have likely come out
with a special issue if NC Catholic missed the news cycle for Sept.
11.
The initial cutback in publication was financially driven, said
Strange, who operates NC Catholic with just one part-time staff writer.
To make up for the decreased number of issues, NC Catholic, like
Chicago, went to more pages. In the case of the NC Catholic, the paper
grew from an average of 16 pages to 24 or more for most issues.
For most newspapers, the big ticket item is mailing costs. NC
Catholic costs more than $5,000 per issue to mail, Strange said.
Like Long Islands OConnor, Strange worries that
changes in New York and Chicago could happen elsewhere.
The newspapers in Chicago and New York have been models for
the rest of us because theyre such big, important newspapers, he
said. I think the question is, How much of a role model are they
going to be for the other dioceses [after the cutbacks]? Its going
to be interesting to see if the other dioceses are going to follow that
leadership.
In Los Angeles, Dennis Heaney, executive publisher of The
Tidings, says he would hate to see his publication frequency reduced. With
strong support from Cardinal Roger Mahony, the archdiocesan Catholic weekly has
a circulation of 92,000 at a subsidized subscription cost of $10 per year for
51 mailed issues. In addition, Heaney oversees the publication of Vida
Nueva, a free Spanish language Catholic weekly with a circulation of
65,000. It is distributed in churches and neighborhood markets.
Reduced publication, Heaney said, just means that much less
contact between the church and the people in the pew on a regular
basis.
This is the way the church gets its message out, he
said, referring to the Catholic press. And, boy, if anything has become
evident since Sept. 11, it is that the church needs to communicate with the
people, and the people want to have a stronger interest in things
spiritual.
Theres a sadness thats going on now that some of
these papers arent able to reach the people on as regular a basis as they
used to. ... This is outreach; this is evangelization.
Patrick ONeill is a freelance writer living in Raleigh,
N.C.
National Catholic Reporter, November 16,
2001
|