Church in
Crisis Cardinal admits silence about priest abuser
By ARTHUR JONES
Los Angeles
The clergy sex abuse headlines have moved West with a vengeance.
Now its Los Angeles Cardinal Roger Mahonys turn to face the public
ire. Mahony, previously heralded as media savvy, admitted May 14 to
archdiocesan priests that he had kept quiet about an abusive priest for 16
years.
The cardinals admission came just before the Los Angeles
Times published an investigation into the cover-up of Mahonys
transfers of known sex abuser Fr. Michael Stephen Baker. The paper said the
results of the investigation will be published soon.
According to a story in the May 16 Los Angeles
Times, Baker told Mahony in 1986 he had been abusing boys, but the
cardinal continued to transfer Baker to other parishes where the abuse
continued. In 2000, Baker was allowed to quietly retire from the
archdiocese, after Mahony had already approved a $1.3 million settlement to two
men who claimed Baker had abused them.
In that complaint, said the Times, Lynne M. Cadigan, the
lawyer representing the men, stated, No one at the archdiocese of Los
Angeles, including Cardinal Mahony, reported Bakers sexual abuse of
children to the authorities, to the parents of the abused children, or to any
other foreseeable victims. Nor did they attempt to find out all the children he
had molested.
This latest case is one of two that could publicly squeeze Mahony
into a situation similar to the one plaguing Bostons Cardinal Bernard
Law.
The other is the December 2001 settlement of $5.2 million to Ryan
DiMaria in Orange, a diocese within Mahonys purview as archbishop.
The California public knows that it was DiMaria who forced the Los
Angeles archdiocese to adopt its zero tolerance policy toward
sexually abusive priests as part of a settlement the month before Bostons
headlines broke.
Law school graduate DiMaria fought a four-year legal battle with
the archdiocese over the abuse he suffered as a teenager from his Catholic high
school principal, Msgr. Michael Harris. DiMaria fought his case alone, though
there were other, separate charges against Harris.
DiMaria, who is in his late 20s, through his lawyer insisted that
the archdiocese establish a one-strike zero tolerance approach to
abuse, including an 800 number for victims and their families. Once those
policies were in place, DiMaria accepted what is considered the largest payout
in a sex abuse case.
Since December, Mahony has been able to use the tough policy as an
indication of his seriousness in dealing with the problem and its fallout.
There have been letters to parishioners, apologies, promises and public
appearances to smooth a frazzled and bewildered Catholic flock and assuage
public disgust.
Even so, only under constant pressure from the Los Angeles
Times since then has Mahony given details, supplying a little information
at a time, about names provided to the police of priests who were known
abusers. And at the time of the April trip by U.S. cardinals to Rome, Mahony
had achieved some visibility.
Reporter Beth Shuster in the Times wrote April 28,
The trip to Vatican City gave Mahony the opportunity to present himself
as a reformer, and even his critics were impressed, if not convinced.
Some of the unconvinced include Times staffers, who have
been digging into the now-breaking Baker case. Baker is accused, said the
Times, of molesting at least nine youths since 1976. The cardinal, in
his preemptive letter to priests warned of the forthcoming media story.
Arthur Jones is NCR editor at large. His e-mail address
is ajones96@aol.com
National Catholic Reporter, May 24,
2002
|