Issue Date: September 24, 2004
Religious political advocates refute partisanship charge
By JOE FEUERHERD
Theres a new dirty word in politics: surrogate.
Democrats charge, for example, that the Swift Boat Boys act as agents of the Bush campaign, however much they plead their independence.
Republicans, meanwhile, see the millions poured into political advertising by Moveon.org and other such 527 groups as evidence of illegal collusion between the Kerry campaign and Bush-hating liberals.
Among Bush campaign surrogates, said Shaun Casey, Wesley Theological Seminary assistant professor of Christian ethics, is the New York-based Catholic League for Civil and Religious Rights. A simple peek at the groups Web site will demonstrate their overt support for Bush, said Casey.
If the Catholic League is a surrogate, said Ethics and Public Policy Center vice president Michael Cromartie, Caseys co-panelist at an Aug. 30 discussion of religion and politics, then so is Sojourners, the Washington-based Christian ministry that aims to proclaim and practice the biblical call to integrate spiritual renewal and social justice.
Theres some evidence for Caseys view. On the leagues Web site, 12 of 24 news releases issued between July 2 and Sept. 8 are explicitly critical of John Kerry or Democrats. None challenge President Bush or the Republican Party. Among those releases were four in which league president William Donohue criticized the appointment of the Rev. Brenda Bartella Peterson as senior religion adviser to the Democratic National Committee. Peterson provoked Donohues wrath because she signed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of Michael Newdow, the California atheist who argued that under God should be removed from the Pledge of Allegiance.
She resigned her national committee position shortly after Donohue began his campaign against her.
Previously, in late June, Donohue criticized the Kerry campaign for hiring Mara Vanderslice as director of religious outreach. Vanderslice kept her job, but plans to make her the campaigns public point person on religious issues were shelved.
Donohue, however, denies hes in the tank for the Bush campaign.
Clearly Im not an enthusiast for Kerry these days, Donohue told NCR, citing the senators pro-choice views. But I dont trust the Republicans and Im not interested in making the Catholic League an analog to the Christian Coalition, which is the Christian arm of the Republican Party.
That lack of trust dates back to at least early 2000, recalled Donohue, when the league was harshly critical of Republican efforts to deny a Catholic priest the job of chaplain to the House of Representatives. A number of prominent Catholic Republican conservatives got on my case very strongly and told me to back off -- that I was hurting the Catholic cause, recalled Donohue. He continued, Some of these people expect everyone to line up single file and report to duty and [resent it when] they find out youre independent, even though you share some of their philosophical opinions.
Still, Donohue, a registered Independent, is aware of the perception that hes taking marching orders from the Republican National Committee or the Bush campaign. Im getting flak from my own members about it, he said. Some of that goes back to his attacks on Vanderslice and Peterson.
I got two scalps and Im proud of that, said Donohue. But to those who suspect hes coordinating his activities with Republican operatives -- that, for example, the information on Vanderslice and Peterson was fed to him -- Donohue scoffs. He says he used publicly available databases -- Google and LexisNexis -- to get the information. If I depended on those [Republican Party] dopes, said Donohue, nothing would have happened.
The Rev. Jim Wallis, executive director of Sojourners, is equally adamant that Sojourners and Call to Renewal, its sister organization, are nonpartisan operations. There is no coordination whatsoever between Sojourners, Call to Renewal and the Kerry campaign, said Wallis.
In fact, said Wallis, he has consistently argued, the Democrats should not make the same mistake the Republicans have made, which is to co-opt the religious community for a partisan agenda. Religion, said Wallis, serves us best when it is not ideologically predictable or loyally partisan.
That nonpartisanship was most recently demonstrated, said Wallis, in the full-page advertisement Sojourners sponsored in The New York Times. That ad -- headlined God is Not a Republican. Or a Democrat. -- said, Sincere Christians and other people of faith can choose to vote for President Bush or Senator Kerry -- for reasons deeply rooted in their faith.
But nonpartisanship does not preclude harsh criticism of the religious right. Theyre not just endorsing George Bush, theyre ordaining George Bush as Gods candidate, Wallis said of such religious right leaders as Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson.
And nonpartisanship doesnt preclude criticism or praise related to issues. Wallis opposes abortion rights and has criticized Democrats on that and other issues. Ive challenged the Democrats on not being champions for the poor [and many Democrats] have been weak and unclear on Iraq.
The Iraq war, it seems, is to the religious left what abortion is to the religious right. George Bushs war in Iraq violates fundamental Christian ethics and values and he should be held electorally accountable for that, said Wallis.
The pope opposes the war on religious grounds, said Wallis. Does that make him a surrogate for John Kerry?
Joe Feuerherd is NCR Washington correspondent. His e-mail address is firstname.lastname@example.org.
National Catholic Reporter, September 24, 2004
|Copyright © The
National Catholic Reporter Publishing Company, 115 E. Armour Blvd.,
Kansas City, MO 64111
All rights reserved.
TEL: 816-531-0538 FAX: 1-816-968-2280 Send comments about this Web site to: email@example.com