This week's stories | Home Page
Issue Date:  February 4, 2005

Growing up is hard to do

'In Good Company' and 'Finding Neverland' show men learning to mature


In Good Company, a new comedy written and directed by Paul Weitz, starts out as if it’s going to be a satiric exposé of contemporary corporate culture. It settles, however, for something less: being a good-natured comedy about the relationship between two men of different generations who find themselves misplaced by the vagaries of business. Dan Foreman (Dennis Quaid), the likable 51-year-old head of advertising for “Sports America,” is suddenly replaced by a 26-year-old hotshot, Carter Duryea (Topher Grace), who has apparently impressed someone in the parent company because of his success in selling cell phones to children. The movie’s exaggerations don’t quite work since the slightly built Carter doesn’t seem to have the needed self-confidence to inspire the world of corporate sharks. His opening remarks to underlings about “synergy” come through as farcical rather than impressive, and he’s incapable of saying “fired” to employees who are deemed expendable. This means that Dan, worried about a fall in income after his wife tells him she is soon to have a third child, is still indispensable though he is officially Carter’s subordinate.

The developing relationship between the two men is really the center of the film. Carter is clearly beyond his depth -- his wife of seven months has just told him she’s leaving -- while Dan has the underlying strength of a much-loved husband and father and enough experience to be unimpressed by the whims of corporate intrigue. “In Good Company” is mistakenly being marketed as a romantic comedy, but though its plot mechanics include an improbable and tasteless affair between Carter and Dan’s daughter Alex (Scarlett Johansson), a glamorous 18-year-old university student, the movie is really about a corporate boy wonder growing up under the tutelage of a older man who knows who he is. Dennis Quaid, as reliable as he is strong, seems capable of making old-fashioned masculinity attractive again. “In Good Company” doesn’t try for realism, but has enough clever lines and shrewd humor to make the final result likable hokum.

Finding Neverland, now up for several Academy Awards, including Best Picture, is based on the play by Allan Knee, “The Man Who Was Peter Pan,” and tells the story of how J.M. Barrie came to write his classic. Johnny Depp as Barrie shows Victorian reserve and youthful charm as he plays in a park with the four attractive boys of the widowed Sylvia Llewelyn Davies (Kate Winslet). He teaches them how to make spoons stick to their noses and is able to persuade them that his shaggy dog is a bear.

Sylvia’s mother (Julie Christie) disapproves of Barrie making himself part of this family, but the film goes to some pains to repress any suspicion that his devotion to the boys is unhealthy. The movie leaves scenes and lines in the memory, particularly about the early death of Barrie’s own brother, that help to explain why he needs to believe in Neverland. Lots of questions remain open, however, since Barrie seems to completely ignore his social-climbing wife (Radha Mitchell).

What made “Neverland” work for me is that it is largely presented as a play within the movie, with backstage confusion, comic rehearsals and Dustin Hoffman as a worried manager who stands to lose money on the show. Older children may rebel at the film’s old-fashioned sweetness, but parents might want to introduce those up through the sixth grade to something beyond cartoonish vulgarity. Director Marc Forster shows a good feel for the period of the story, the music is attractive and affirmative, as is the setting, and it’s hard not to be charmed by the ease with which the children fly. Barrie doesn’t really have an answer when Peter, the boy he is closest to, asks, “Why do people have to die?” but his honesty shows that the film is wise enough to avoid total escapism.

Joseph Cunneen is NCR’s regular movie reviewer. His e-mail address is

Quick Takes
Coach Carter is yet another inspirational sports movie, but it has the advantage of having Samuel L. Jackson as the man whose tough love turns Richmond High’s losing basketball team into a state powerhouse. Too much is predictable and characterization is superficial, but “Coach Carter” nevertheless offers a real challenge to the many schools in depressed districts that exploit their athletes and fail to prepare them for any real future.

National Catholic Reporter, February 4, 2005

This Week's Stories | Home Page | Top of Page
Copyright  © The National Catholic Reporter Publishing  Company, 115 E. Armour Blvd., Kansas City, MO   64111
All rights reserved.
TEL:  816-531-0538     FAX:  1-816-968-2280   Send comments about this Web site to: