|Cover story -- Palestinians|
Issue Date: November 24, 2006
Life in a perpetual standoff
By CHRIS HERLINGER
First of two parts
On a recent November morning, in between his administrative hospital rounds and amid various workers strikes, continuing political uncertainty and growing worry that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was on the verge of yet another cycle of spiraling violence, Dr. Tawfiq Nasser pulled out his wallet and showed a visitor his identification cards.
In this country, we have a habit of collecting cards, the Palestinian doctor said dryly.
He held up three cards in quick succession: a magnetic security card to expedite his way through Israeli checkpoints; an identification card issued by the Palestinian Authority; and a third card certifying that he works for a nongovernmental organization: in this case, for the Lutheran World Federation, for which he serves as head of the Augusta Victoria Hospital in Jerusalem and also oversees the hospitals program of village health clinics in various parts of the West Bank.
Nassers main focus, and worry, however, was about a permit due to expire the next day that allowed him to enter Israeli territory and return to his office in Jerusalem. A strike by Israeli bureaucrats was suddenly complicating his life -- without a new permit, he and his staff would be stranded.
The sudden concern about the permit overtook Nassers rapid-fire explanation about the fragmented health care system in the Palestinian territories. He argued that as long as an occupation exists, with its attendant checkpoints, delays and transportation snafus, villagers closer to one city to will be forced to go to another for their basic health care. And as a result, their health will suffer.
With a sudden, unexpected snafu about permits added to the mix, Nasser began to lose patience, becoming increasingly impassioned and angry as he spoke to a visitor. All of our lives are run by bureaucrats in a settlement. You tell me this is no occupation, that it this is just security, he said.
Tomorrow, I dont know if I can go to work, he said, his voice rising. And who is punished? The patients. Hamas, theyre not punished. Its my patients.
Declarations of impatience, frustration and outright anger are becoming increasingly common among Palestinians these days -- particularly those whose faces and voices are too rarely seen or heard in depictions of Palestinian reality in the West.
The moderate sector of teachers, academics, students, government officials and doctors -- the vanguard of Palestinian civil society who are not questioning the permanence of the state of Israel, even though they are clearly fed up with the politics of the Israeli occupation -- have, by dint of professional training and patience, kept day-to-day Palestinian society running. They have done so amid an ongoing political stalemate between rival political factions, militants and the Israeli government, and a humanitarian situation that has been worsening by the week.
Weary of politics but keenly aware that just about everything in their contested land is highly political, they are increasingly pessimistic about any resolution to their plight.
Something of their situation was summed up recently by Latin Patriarch Michel Sabbah of Jerusalem, a longtime champion of Palestinian rights, when he met earlier this month with a group of American journalists who write for Catholic publications.
Speaking of the situation in the Gaza Strip but also about the fate of Palestinians generally, Sabbah said: They are not terrorists; they are people who are living under oppression and who are reacting. And not all of them are reacting. There are Palestinians who dont react at all, who go on living their lives in despair and humiliation and poverty. They go on living under occupation without any reaction.
Others feel similarly -- with a pronounced touch of pessimism. Were going nowhere, Rafik Husseini, the chief of staff to President Mahmoud Abbas, said during an interview at the Palestinian Authoritys headquarters in Ramallah.
Sulieman Harb Shalaldeh, the mayor of the municipality of Sier, near the city of Hebron, expressed the hope that he could soon govern normally.
Let us keep the politics outside so that our people can continue their lives, Shalaldeh said recently to the group of journalists. Shalaldeh has to deal with competing political claims, day-to-day-tensions, and now strikes by frustrated Palestinian workers who have not been paid since U.S.-led international sanctions and cuts to the Palestinian Authority by the Israeli government were imposed in March. The cuts by the Israelis alone have resulted in a monthly loss of $50 million in customs receipts.
The mayors comments were echoed by a teacher who greeted her American guests with fresh fruit, cakes and tea. The majority of Palestinians, 90 percent, have no relationship with politics, she said. But politics are reflected severely in their daily life.
So is history. To an outsider what is perhaps most striking in Palestinian refugee settlements and other public spaces are murals depicting uprooted villages lost for 50 years or more, with some still clinging to keys and land titles of areas now occupied by Israeli homes, public spaces and even shopping malls.
Given the overwhelming sense of history and grievance that prevails here, the teachers name is all the more revealing. The woman speaking was named Palestine Hussein.
Facts on the ground
The phrase facts on the ground is often used to describe the reality of what Palestinians see as the things that make a viable Palestinian state and society difficult if not outright impossible: Israeli settlements, outposts, settler roads, checkpoints, the routing of a 420-mile separation barrier. But it just as easily could describe the deleterious humanitarian situation in the Palestinian territories themselves.
The territories gross domestic product stands at $1,183 per capita, according to the World Health Organization. Unemployment rates overall stand at 25.3 percent, while rates of poverty overall are 56 percent. The poverty rate in the impoverished Gaza Strip stands at an astonishing 80 percent.
The populations socioeconomic conditions and access to health care are severely affected by lack of contiguity between the West Bank and Gaza and restrictions on movements, the World Health Organization said in a recent summary.
Current conditions -- exacerbated by an unsettled political situation -- are believed to have worsened humanitarian problems: Chronic malnutrition has long been a problem in the territories and has been particularly acute in Gaza, where a 2003 study by CARE International indicated that 13.3 percent of small children in Gaza suffered from chronic malnutrition -- 11 percent higher than a normally nourished population would suffer.
What precipitated the current crisis was the January victory of the political faction Hamas in Palestinian Legislative Council elections. Hamas victory in turn led to international sanctions that have cut assistance to the Palestinian Authority -- a move that Palestinians have decried as unfair and unjust.
You wanted democracy and now when you see the fruit of our democracy you say, No, we will boycott you. Sabbah said about the popular reaction to the move: This is wrong, unfair and unjust for the Palestinian people.
The Israeli and U.S. governments said sanctions are justified because Hamas is a terrorist organization. Palestinians -- and this includes those aligned with the rival political faction Fatah -- acknowledge and even embrace Hamas militancy. But they have also stressed what they say is Hamas political and humanitarian roots and argue that Hamas is no al-Qaeda. In fact, they contend, beginning in the 1970s, Israel itself helped foster the creation of Hamas as an Islamic alternative to the secular Palestine Liberation Organization.
The Israeli and U.S. governments have interpreted the Hamas victory as a worrisome sign of growing Palestinian and Islamic militancy, while Palestinians have tended to view the Hamas victory as a protest vote and a referendum on what they say was a corrupt and out-of-touch Fatah elite that had, the sentiment went, cravenly compromised with Israel during the 1990s. (While Hamas controls the Palestinian legislature, President Mahmoud Abbas is aligned with Fatah.)
Over dinner at a Ramallah restaurant, Nader Said, a development studies specialist who teaches at Birzeit University, said public sentiment went something like this: Lets try Hamas; we know Hamas wont work, but lets stick to our identity. He said that Hamas had hit a deep public nerve.
However one defines Hamas and interprets the elections, the results proved a smashing blow in at least one respect: Western sanctions remain in place against the Palestinian government, with assistance being cut off until Hamas recognizes Israels right to exist and renounces violence against Israel.
These demands form the core of contention between various the Palestinian factions and were cause for continued dispute recently between Hamas and Fatah over a new compromise prime minister. The current prime minister, Ismail Haniyeh of Hamas, has said he would resign if it would help restore international assistance to the Palestinian government.
The practical result of all of this is that salaries for some 140,000 government workers are not being paid -- prompting a joke by Husseini, the presidential chief of staff. He said recently on a Sunday evening that he was beginning his second work shift, at no pay. I knew this would be a 75 percent reduction of pay, he said. I didnt expect it would be 100 percent.
Jokes aside, the sanctions have not only caused obvious hardships but also prompted a 70-day teachers strike, as well as walkouts by other public employees. Worsening day-to-day public services have become the norm.
The boycott has had a devastating and cumulative effect, said Tom Garofalo, the Jerusalem-based country representative for Catholic Relief Services. Things are declining geometrically.
Maybe not indefinitely, however: The end of the teachers strike Nov. 11 proved a major relief, and Arab nations that had joined the boycott have announced they will drop it, in part because of anger over a recent Israeli military attack in Gaza.
Nonetheless, reminders of what has been a stark, confusing and dispiriting time are everywhere: A school built with assistance from Catholic Relief Services in the village of Sier recently stood empty. A group of school administrators and parents huddled around a small administrative office and said both they and students have felt stranded and isolated by the strike and the international boycott, which they said have worsened the day-to-day hardships imposed by the occupation.
What can we do? said headmaster Ahed Mohid Jebreen who, like the parents, spoke about their coping mechanisms in an economy that has stalled -- be it borrowing from shop owners (and piling up debts), or selling family jewelry to pay bills.
All the world is punishing us for our democracy, and that is not fair, Jebreen said. Such punishment, he and the others stressed, is not punishing Hamas, but punishing the struggling Palestinian middle class and poor people.
A recent survey spearheaded by Saids Development Studies Program confirmed those anecdotal observations: Of 1,200 persons surveyed in September, nearly three-quarters said their daily lives and living conditions had become worst since the January elections.
The survey also revealed that while Hamas popularity has declined precipitously -- from 50 percent in April to a mere 31 percent five months later -- a majority of those polled still thought Hamas should form a coalition government. And a majority, 62.3 percent, also said Hamas should not be expected to recognize Israel immediately. The poll also found that distrust of the United States was as widespread and deep as could possibly be: a full 94.4 percent said the United States had not played a constructive role in resolving the Israeli-Palestinian standoff.
This tense environment has also affected the response of American humanitarian agencies, such as Catholic Relief Services, that receive U.S. government funding for projects in the Palestinian territories. Catholic Relief Services has to abide by a no-contact rule with all Hamas officials, though it can still keep contact with such national bodies as the Palestinian presidents office.
As a practical result, that means the Catholic agency has had to roll with some big changes, Garofalo said. It has also made it occasionally difficult for local staff who, like any on-the-ground humanitarian workers, must deal with local authorities and governments no matter what their political affiliation. We can function, but it has been difficult for our staff who work in Hebron, Bethlehem and Gaza, Garofalo said.
These and other difficulties have changed a society that despite its many challenges was, in Saids words, vibrant and hopeful. Now, day-to-day life seems more fragmentary and pinched, with horizons eclipsing. The whole dream of a Palestinian state is in danger, he said.
Well do the small things we do each day, he said. But the big picture is desperate.
He paused for a moment. Were asked, Why do you have fundamentalists? he said. His response: Its because you are closing all of the windows of fresh air.
That is perhaps nowhere more evident than in Gaza, a place other Palestinians call everything from a prison to a mental asylum.
Potential powder keg
It doesnt take long to learn that Gaza can break your heart.
A sunny Mediterranean outpost that contains some of the most crowded and densely populated urban areas on the planet, Gaza is an impoverished and dispiriting place until you listen to college-age students and young people speak passionately about furthering their skills in computer sciences and English -- although they do so amid the more-than-occasional and not terribly distant cracks of gunfire rounds.
Kidnappings are common here -- though it is said that they often stem more from boredom than from any political or even monetary motivation -- and have added to the sense of a powder keg in the making.
Now in the hands of the Palestinian Authority after a series of well-publicized withdrawals by Israel, Gaza is distinctly different from the West Bank, where Israeli and Palestinian communities collide and jut into each other. In Gaza, a sense of isolation and even imprisonment has taken root, resulting in ennui at best, contempt and extremism at worst.
Throw whatever you want at us is how presidential chief of staff Husseini describes popular sentiment in Gaza. They are desperate. They have no hope. And they have nothing to lose but their chains.
It is from Gaza that small, homemade rockets are often fired into Israel, prompting what Palestinians have called Israeli overreaction, but what Israel has declared as justified security measures of self-defense.
I know the Gaza people are suffering, said Bahij Mansour, a one-time member of the Israeli diplomatic corps who now heads Israels department of religious affairs and who spoke on Israeli policies recently to a group of Americans. But he said that Israel feels justified in protecting its borders along the Gaza Strip.
It is Gaza, in the town of Beit Hanoun, that drew worldwide focus recently when Israeli artillery killed 18 Palestinians -- including 13 members of a single family -- in a military operation that was criticized internationally and resulted in a United Nations Security Council resolution of condemnation that was vetoed by the United States. Israel, apparently embarrassed by an incident that killed primarily women and children, called the shelling a mistake. The move prompted new threats of suicide bombings, as well as fury throughout the Arab-speaking world and even talk of a third intifada within the occupied territories.
If the long-term ramifications of the Israeli action and the Palestinian response remain to be seen, it is not hard to imagine that the voices of Palestinian moderates in Gaza may become harder to hear.
Mohammed Ismail, 22, is one such voice. Active in a Gaza youth leadership program, Ismail is a one-time English student, an avid reader of Ernest Hemingway, and has hopes of studying English at the graduate level. He acknowledged that Gaza residents have reached a level of anger where they are not afraid of losing everything.
At the same time, though, he knows there are liberals in Israel who do not support their governments policies toward the Palestinians and wishes there was a way for them to make common cause with Palestinians like himself.
One reason he believes that should remain a priority is because of a simple truism, recognized by many but maybe by not all on both the Palestinian and Israeli divide.
We are here, they are there. Were not leaving, and theyre not leaving.
Chris Herlinger, a New York freelance journalist, recently traveled to Israel and the Palestinian territories as part of a prize for Catholic Relief Services Eileen Egan Award for Journalistic Excellence, which he won for reporting on Darfur for NCR in 2005. Photographer Paul Jeffrey, also an Egan Award winner, assisted with the reporting for this article.
National Catholic Reporter, November 24, 2006
|Copyright © The
National Catholic Reporter Publishing Company, 115 E. Armour Blvd.,
Kansas City, MO 64111
All rights reserved.
TEL: 816-531-0538 FAX: 1-816-968-2280 Send comments about this Web site to: email@example.com