Churchs clout may be waning, but N.Y. is
still the bulliest pulpit
By ARTHUR
JONES NCR Staff New York
NEW YORK -- Fourteen years ago John OConnor stood on the
altar steps in St. Patricks Cathedral after his installation as New
Yorks archbishop. He stuck his miter on the head of a startled
10-year-old altar boy -- also named John OConnor -- jammed a N.Y. Yankees
baseball cap on his own head and mimicked the mayor, Ed Koch, by saying,
Howm I doin?
So how is the former chief of naval chaplains doing? More than
that, what will it be like in the not-too-distant future for someone to try to
fill the size 9-1/2 shoes of this former Philadelphia priest?
To get some answers to both questions, NCR interviewed
people from the archdioceses rural villages to the Lower East Side, from
the suburbs to Harlem; talking to priests and pols, women religious and
writers.
Although OConnor submitted his resignation to Pope John Paul
II three years ago, the 78-year-old cardinal is doing everything he can to
delay the inevitable.
Just as the pope wants to open St. Peters doors to the new
millennium in 2000, OConnor, who became the eighth archbishop of New York
in 1984, would love to do the same at St. Patricks. And the pope seems to
be leaving elderly archbishops where they are.
All thats been said officially is that the pope has told
OConnor to continue until other provisions are made.
However much longer he might have in his position, OConnor
has carved out a distinctive era as leader of arguably the most prestigious
archdiocese in the country.
During this era, the New York media has followed his comings and
goings to a degree not experienced by any other U.S. religious figure.
OConnor has handled life at center stage during a period when the
politics and religion of the country have been bitterly divided over such
issues as abortion and the rights of homosexuals.
Through it all, OConnor has sometimes declared boldly on
topics and, at other times, humbly and self-deprecatingly apologized, sometimes
over the same issue.
He has certainly made mistakes, but he is not afraid to admit
them. As he told NCR (see accompanying interview), if he had it to do
over again, he would handle quite differently his celebrated clash with
then-vice presidential candidate Geraldine Ferraro. At the time, some found him
courageous; others found him foolish.
His successor will have to continue handling difficult and complex
questions as put by the overheated New York media with its insatiable appetite
for the sound byte.
OConnor, with his resolute refusal to close parishes and
schools despite the advice of business experts, has avoided some of the
controversies that have torn other dioceses. But even some who have benefited
from his determination to keep Catholic institutions open believe his successor
will face inevitable, difficult and even expensive choices in that area.
OConnor, meanwhile, says he still has work to do. If anyone
needs a testament to his physical fitness, watch him as he hops and skips up
and down St. Patricks sanctuary steps. So many around him have warned
OConnor that hes going to trip and break a hip that the cardinal
finally wrote a lighthearted column about it in Catholic New York, the
archdiocesan weekly.
Again, almost as if to prove to the pope -- and himself -- that he
is still physically on top of his job, OConnor in October took a grueling
round trip to Melbourne, Australia. Then, in January, along with his pal the
pope, he was out in Cubas noonday sun. In depicting New York, nearly
every person NCR interviewed used the same two words, diversity
and complexity. In describing OConnor, many said,
tireless.
OConnor tries to be hands-on in most places. His
visibility is enormous, said Msgr. Wallace Harris of Harlems St.
Charles Borromeo Parish. We call Catholic New York the
cardinals weekly agenda, but when you take a step back to look at it you
say, My God, he did all this this week?
Stamina essential
There is a feeling in some quarters that he tries to micro-manage.
Nonetheless, if nothing else, New Yorks newcomer will have to have
stamina.
Energy is a quality New Yorkers admire, and New Yorkers
doesnt just mean Manhattanites. The New York archdiocese is a
10-county, 4,683-square-mile region. It changes its character rapidly. In
Manhattan its a bustling, coldhearted/warmhearted, overcrowded city with
plenty of examples of extremes, rich and poor. Staten Island is working
class/middle class; the Bronx is poor and working class. Then, almost next
door, come the comfortable suburbs of Westchester County, where the better-off
middle class and the wealthy of Wall Street and the corporate suite rest their
busy heads. Beyond that are rural Sullivan and Ulster counties.
In growing but rural Orange County, for example, New York City
firemen live and commute into the city for their live-in-the-station shifts.
Far out though they may dwell, for New Yorkers Manhattan ultimately is the
lodestone.
New York is the world, says one of its Catholics, Bill
Baker, president of Channel 13-WNET, the public television station on West 58th
St. And New Yorkers are people from all corners of it. They create
it, he says. As New Yorkers, theyre smart -- in the sense of
sophistication, of intellectualism and of the street. Street
smart.
Some outsiders, of course, may be inclined to describe New Yorkers
as pushy, aggressive, aloof and rude. Where others might see aggression, Baker
sees passion. New Yorkers are committed -- and passionate about those
commitments. New Yorkers are inquiring, critical, creative. New York is about
creating and re-creating, interpreting and defining.
Catholic New Yorkers, in Bakers view, are perceived as
mainline, conservative, established. They are at once the remnant of the
European white immigrant church and American to the core. They embody American
values in their Catholic tradition. The new immigrant Catholics in New York are
diverse -- Asian, Latin American, Caribbean, African and European. They, too,
are traditional. But in a different way from the historic European
groups.
Decades ago, G.K. Chestertons take was that New York
is a cosmopolitan city, but it is not a city of cosmopolitans. Most of the
masses in New York have a nation, whether or not it be the nation in which New
York belongs. They are exiles or they are citizens; there is no moment when
they are cosmopolitans. But very often exiles bring with them not only rooted
traditions but rooted truths.
One rooted truth is that in New York City any newcomer archbishop
will have to risk being burned by the media, bashed by the politicians and
wooed -- or spurned --by the money.
Where, in todays larger public realm, does a Catholic
archbishop fit?
Less prominently than previously, in the view of Columbia
University history professor Alan Brinkley, a New Yorker but not a Catholic. He
sees OConnor -- and by extension any future Catholic archbishop of New
York -- playing an increasingly less important role in the life of the
city, as the traditionally Irish Catholic population of New York declines, as
the church itself becomes less central to the lives of its own
members.
While Brinkley acknowledges that Cardinal OConnor is
still a considerable presence, he adds, I dont think anything
like his predecessors were. Brinkley would remind a newcomer that
Manhattan is not New York and that Manhattan in particular is not
Catholic New York. (Manhattan is actually 39.4 percent Catholic.)
Brinkley would also caution any new archbishop against being drawn
into the maelstrom of New York society and politics. Brinkley doesnt
think OConnor -- with whom he sometimes agrees and sometimes doesnt
-- has been careful enough in that regard.
Once you start to try to exert political influence and prove
to have none, then youre diminishing your spiritual influence as
well, he said.
In 1984, shortly after OConnor arrived, columnist Jimmy
Breslin touched on the same topic in a different way. He referred to him as
Yesterday OConnor.
Gone are the days, said Breslin in the New York Daily News,
when a New York cardinals residence at 452 Madison Avenue could be called
the powerhouse.Gone the time when the man at that switch
controlled political offices, government careers, money, real estate and
peoples social standing. Wrote Breslin, that was
yesterday.
Yesterday, he continued, was when a phone call
from the powerhouse could kill a front page story. The way
OConnor has acted in this city so far, he doesnt seem to realize
that yesterday has passed.
Paul Crotty is well-known on the New York political scene. Until
recently he was New York Citys corporate counsel; hes now a Bell
Atlantic senior vice-president.
Speaking of the man who will one day succeed OConnor, Crotty
said an incoming archbishop has got to respect the diversity --
thats the key thing, those different cultures and civilizations that
populate New York.
The new man also needs to know, said Crotty, that New York
politics can be very, very tough and fractious. Cardinal OConnor,
looking back on it, thought he could communicate with people over the heads of
everyone simply by going directly to the press. I think the press took
advantage of him.
In his later years, said Crotty, the cardinal has been saying less
and accomplishing more.
When you enter into the public relations fray in New York
City, theres no respect, said Crotty, Youve got to be
above it to command respect. And I think the cardinal is held in far higher
regard now.
As Newsday columnist Bill Reel, a Catholic to the
conservative side of center, sees it, New York is the media capital of
the world. The financial capital of the world. Any new archbishop has to be
conscious that everything he says will be heard, analyzed and commented
on.
For any major figure New York City, with four high-circulation
daily newspapers, dozens of television stations and hundreds of corner kiosks
filled with Manhattan-fixated magazines, is a very public place.
In New Yorks liberal media, abortion is a
religion, Reel said. They will not tolerate any attack on what they
regard as a priceless human right.
A new archbishop strong on the life issues should not expect to be
well-received editorially by The New York Times, Newsday or
Daily News, said Reel, though hell find The New York Post
sympathetic.
The Daily News Bill Bell, a writer who has traveled
overseas with OConnor and has been on 14 papal global journeys, said that
a new archbishop needs to understand that the citys media is fickle, has
a short attention span, but during that short period, the scrutiny is
intense and in some cases partisan.
Bell, not an uncritical observer (his version of OConnor in
Beirut is hilarious), sees OConnor as an effective communicator -- though
he doesnt talk to the press anymore. Hes gotten burned many
times by his talk-first, think-later style. At one time
OConnors episcopal motto was said to be: Shoot, Aim,
Ready.
The Daily News writer regards the cardinal as a
pretty good writer -- something nobody gives him credit for.
OConnors weekly column in the archdiocesan newspaper,
said Bell, is interesting and readable. It keeps him in touch with his
flock and also enables him to kind of set the record straight. He believes the
press simplifies and abbreviates his thoughts -- and thats true. So he
uses the column to amplify and clarify.
The new guy will need to do the same. And, said Bell,
hell find himself defending Vatican teaching so often on things
that are not very popular, hell begin to sound like a broken record --
but thats what his job is. Plus, concluded Bell, getting in a plug,
the next archbishop needs to understand the needs of the electronic media
and print media are very different.
Says Newsdays Reel, What I admire about
OConnor is he stands up and says what he thinks. An archbishop of New
York has to keep on saying what he believes even if nobodys agreeing with
him.
It can pay off: Theres a lot of Catholic money in Wall
Street, the corporations, the city and the suburbs, and I think a willingness
to assert the truth of Catholicism plays well with those people, said
Reel.
One fundraiser who has watched OConnor and prefers to remain
unidentified said, Any New York archbishops got to schmooze if he
wants the money. You know, tell the rich they can be better wealthy people if
theyll give some of the wealth away.
OConnor as fundraiser, said the source, is not bad,
but not as good as he thinks he is. Some of these corporate leaders are tough
-- thats how they got where they are. They run big conglomerates.
Theyre forceful. Demanding. Maybe some of them kind of put him off. But
people who give want to meet the king. They want to put the money themselves in
the kings hand. And if you want the money, youve got to be
available.
Schmoozing
Six years ago a major archdiocesan campaign pulled in $100
million. Right now things are financially tight, though just about on an even
keel -- the half-billion-dollar budget ran a recent $3 million deficit; 108
parishes received funds from the interparish finance commission.
Schmoozing with politicians is not an archiepiscopal essential. On
abortion, OConnor has disagreed with New Yorks biggest Catholic
names, including Mario Cuomo when he was governor, Geraldine Ferraro when she
was a vice presidential candidate (now a U.S. Senate candidate), and perennial
Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan.
OConnors eventual successor -- ensconced on the top
floor of his chancery skyscraper, the 20-story Catholic Center at 1011 First
Avenue (between 55th and 56th streets) -- will find that New York is not just
church, but layers of church.
Theres the institutional layer, the work that goes on inside
and emanates from his building. Church also is the parish layer, each parish
with its own personality, pressures and problems. Then theres New York
Catholicisms activist layer, many gradations from urban streets to
migrant ministry. Some agencies, like Catholic Charities, are diocesan, others
are not.
A new archbishop needs to know what women religious are
doing, said Congregation de Notre Dame Sr. Mavie Coakley, who knows
shell get a laugh when she says she operates a Manhattan escort
service.
If the new archbishop tracked women religious, she
said, hed really have a feel for the city. Theyre on every
block. Turn the corner, and theres another group.
(Coakley does operate a kind of escort service, accompanying the
elderly to doctors, the bank and the stores.)
Then theres New York Catholicisms intellectual layer
-- the purveyors of theological, media and academic talk, the social and
literary scuttlebutt, the jests and the jousting.
OConnor tried early to have an impact there. In the early
1980s he hosted monthly sessions, a couple of dozen people at his residence for
drinks and fellowship, in an attempt to develop a place for Catholic dialogue
and consensus across the Catholic spectrum.
These were sessions where Bishop Patrick V. Ahern, retired New
York auxiliary, might close the evening singing Let Me Call You
Sweetheart to the late Helen Hayes, or Richard John Neuhaus might be
found ridiculing Chicago Cardinal Joseph Bernardins seamless
garment approach to life issues.
OConnor more than a decade ago, in effect, was attempting
his own common ground project. The evenings gradually petered
out.
On the institutional front, the new archbishop will face problems
OConnor has deliberately ignored (the need to close and consolidate
parishes) and tackled (the need for vocations). Hell be bound by tighter
budgetary constraints than OConnor inherited and, if hes a youngish
appointee, severe clerical shortages before his term expires. Fifty years ago
the New York archdiocese had 2,097 priests for 1.2 million Catholics. Today New
York has slightly fewer priests than 50 years ago -- 1,911 (895 diocesan, 1,021
religious) -- for twice as many (2.3 million) Catholics. And that number goes
to three million, insists OConnor, when the undocumented are included.
We call him cardinal
OConnor generally has the priests admiration, if not
their affection. OConnor goes out of his way, said one, to make himself
available to the priests. Even so, he said, we called Spellman
Spelly, and Cooke Cookie, but we call the cardinal,
the cardinal.
There are 100 diocesan minor seminarians (45 in major seminary)
compared to a total 616 a half century ago when there were also a further 426
studying in religious order seminaries, a certain percentage of which would be
likely to serve in the archdiocese.
There are no religious order seminaries in the archdiocese today.
Even so, by national standards, OConnor has been doing reasonably well in
recruiting future priests -- though not all seminarians stay the course.
Said Harlems Msgr. Harris, the new fellow will have
some interesting things to face. Cardinal OConnor has adamantly kept
every school open, adamantly kept every church open. The new fellow may have to
take a different view of that. He will have to look at the redistribution of
religious and clergy to be most effective -- whether or not we have a
resurgence right now of small numbers in seminary.
Msgr. William J. Belford, pastor of St. Catharines in
suburban Blauvelt, said, You have to give the cardinal credit for the
number of schools that have remained open when conventional wisdom would have
said they should have been closed years ago.
Its been a real effort but a successful effort, I
think, to find patrons for some schools that would never otherwise be able to
pay the bills. The new archbishop, Belford said, similarly will have to
find patrons and keep them giving if those schools are to
survive.
Everybody agrees, said Belford, that -- especially in the poor
neighborhoods -- these schools are absolutely the only hope for children.
The public schools are disastrous. But I would also point out that in Staten
Island, where the public schools are good, the island Catholic schools are
packed.
The new man coming in has to be a planner, said Msgr.
Neil Connolly, pastor at St. Marys on the Lower East Side. I hear
others saying the same thing. Look at how many parishes we have and why they
were constructed. Im not talking about destroying a community, but just
looking at the physical buildings.
Is there a need to combine some of them?
Connolly thinks so. And he thinks the archdiocese will need
someone who will promote leadership and cooperation on an area basis.
Like a vicariate basis. I think thats really important.
One parish doesnt have all the resources, said
Connolly, and if we had a cooperative-type ministry, much more
cooperative, I think we would do a lot better than we presently do.
Many of the administrative chores -- from boiler permits to
financial record-keeping -- could be done on a multi-parish basis, contended
Connolly.
Another tack for the new man to take, in Connollys view, is
building up the linkages between the inner-city parishes and the suburbs. He
mentioned the Cleveland diocesan approach pushed by Bishop Anthony Pilla.
New Yorks a lot different from Cleveland, said
Connolly, but weve begun talking about these things here.
Its important not just for resources, but for all of us as
Catholics that celebrating church unity begin at home, he said.
Some New York priests worry that the seminarians these days often
are conservative or hyper-orthodox. Harris takes a broad view: The wealth
of New York vocations for years came from its immigrants children,
said Harris, and were not seeing that right now. Even if were
bringing in Catholic immigrants, seminary isnt a priority in many
families lives anymore.
So, continued Harris, the young men who are entering the seminary
are located in a different place geographically or culturally or financially
from earlier generations of seminarians. Harris said the earlier generations
understood the city and were not overwhelmed by its myths.
One of those myths is that inner-city churches are empty. He said
hes brought seminarians to St. Charles for the 9:30 a.m. Mass and
theyre astounded at the people standing in the aisles and all down
the street.
The question of conservative or liberal, said Harris, ebbs and
flows. Hyper-orthodoxy, he said, is a sign of insecurity. There is a
legitimate orthodoxy, said Harris, but hyper-orthodoxy is the easy
way out -- you dont have to think much. But the trend everywhere is that
the pendulum is swinging to the right right now.
Depending on who the new appointee is and who is likely to be
appointing him, that pendulums swing might suit the next archbishop just
fine.
There are some 50,000 working women religious in the United
States. Almost 8 percent of those -- 3,849 -- are in the New York archdiocese,
where significant numbers hold together much of the social service fabric.
Among them, on a personal level, reaction toward
OConnors tenure varies. One commented that as an archdiocese, New
York was pretty dead for women, particularly liturgically. What
saves it, she said, is that because of the archdioceses variety,
you can find something to satisfy your needs.
Society of the Sacred Heart Sr. Judy Garson and Congregation de
Notre Dame Sr. Mary Nearny represent two of the thousands of separate and
intertwined New York stories among the citys women religious. Garson
works with the Little Sisters of the Assumption family health service in East
Harlem; Nearny with abused and incarcerated women.
The Little Sisters, 40 years in the area, do not operate health
clinics or hospitals, explained Garson, but provide a visiting nursing service
in the home. They also provide social services and some lay advocacy.
While the health service is involved with crisis and
immediate service, said Garson, the long-term work is with families
and individuals on education, ESL [English as a Second Language] and support
programs to help them take their own lives in hand.
Aware of their own declining numbers, the Little Sisters service
has recruited laity so that the service is now one-third women religious and
two-thirds lay people.
Champion of the poor
What would Garson tell a new archbishop?
Id presume to tell him that understanding the
diversity and complexity is a large part of his education; that part of the
excitement of this city comes from the fact that the population is always
somewhat in motion, Garson said.
How does OConnor look from East Harlem?
Hes enormously in tune with needs of the immigrant
population, said Garson, at a time when many people pay lip service
to it. The cardinal is a champion of the poor. Weve watched him in all
the convulsions of the health care system. Immigrants. Housing. Rent control.
He speaks out and is very clear on those issues.
The place of the church in a city like this is unique,
said Garson, and not everybody in New York loves the Catholic
churchs institutional face. But it also represents an enormous power. And
it uses that power for the sake of the poorest and the most
vulnerable.
Sr. Nearny has a close-up view of the harshest lives women live --
battered and incarcerated. Over the years shes founded two programs,
Steps To End Family Violence and the Incarcerated Mothers Program.
The work began when Nearny -- who earlier had started a halfway
house for women offenders -- was part of a group attending a hearing inside a
state prison, the first such hearing ever. Twelve women testified about abuse
theyd experienced in their lives and how it was not taken into
consideration in their court cases.
Steps advocates for abused women, works with pro bono
and assigned attorneys and is involved in counseling and support groups. The
Incarcerated Mothers Program attempts to keep mothers and children connected so
the bond is maintained and so she doesnt loose her legal rights as a
parent.
My other life, says Nearny, is fundraising. She has to
find almost $800,000 annually to support the two projects. For three years the
archdiocese has helped out with an $8,000 local Campaign for Human Development
grant.
What, from her perspective, does Nearny believe a new archbishop
needs to understand?
That abuse is a serious situation that needs to be brought to the
pulpit, into churches, she said. And churches in turn -- like one Episcopal
parish in Manhattan and a Catholic parish in Harlem -- need to become places
where services to abused and abusers are developed.
Nearnys other message is that alternatives to incarceration
make a lot of sense for women, and theyre a lot safer.
What else? The archdiocesan office for womens concerns
is one person -- Maria Guarracino -- just this one marvelous woman handling
both a home situation -- her husband is ill -- and the entire archdiocese. But
thats an impossible situation. She needs more people there. (See
profile on page 17 of the paper issue.)
Another element of New York church that contains both the Catholic
and the political has to do with archdiocesan relations with the gay
community.
Jeff Stone, New York-based Dignity national director, said
informal talks continue with the cardinal. We keep publicity off [the
talks] and hope progress can be made, especially in areas where we think there
could be agreement.
Stone was talking about civil, not theological, matters, such as a
pending New York state nondiscrimination bill, and the states first hate
crimes bill, both of which would extend protection to gays.
It would be very gratifying to see the cardinal either
support those bills or not oppose them and make it clear he he was not opposing
them -- make it clear because often there is a lot of misperception surrounding
these issues, he said. Stone said gay Catholics were
gratified by last falls pastoral letter from the U.S. bishops
Always Our Children, which deals with the relationships of
homosexual children and their parents.
Stone said Dignity was hoping OConnor would publicly support
the document and speak out about it as many other bishops had, but he did
not.
On an entirely different front, the next archbishop is certainly
going to cost New York Catholics more than OConnor does. The cardinal
gives his annual Social Security income to a scholarship fund for black
students, gives $18,000 of his Navy pension to charities, keeps $12,000 and
draws no archdiocesan salary.
The cardinal began his New York era by mimicking Ed Koch on the
altar steps of St. Patricks Cathedral. The two of them later wrote a
book, His Eminence and Hizzoner, setting out their views. For now, Koch
gets the last word.
The cardinals been a magnificent friend, not only to
Jewish people but to minorities. Theres been no greater spokesman for the
poor. Ive berated those who would attack him, said Koch, those who
liked it when he spoke out against poverty and on behalf of the poor,
hated it when he spoke out on the issue of abortion. I said, even though I
disagree with him on that issue, why is it OK to speak on things you like but
on matters of conscience youd deprive him?
The former mayor, who says hes spent more time in St.
Patricks than most Catholics, was there the day Act-Up invaded. I
told him Id be there with the cops, said Koch, who was
outraged when the protesters were released without even being
fined at least $100 to $200.
Koch is convinced that OConnor was primarily responsible --
through his personal relationship and credibility with the Holy
Father -- for the change in Vatican policy that resulted in the Vatican
diplomatic recognition of Israel. The cardinal told me early on, at a
breakfast when I was mayor, that his greatest goal was to achieve that
recognition, said Koch. And he did.
(OConnor may have had a supporting role, but the key person
responsible was the popes childhood Jewish friend, Jerzy Kluger (see
The Hidden Pope by Darcy OBrien, reviewed in NCRs May
15 issue [not posted on this site])
What would the mayor tell the next archbishop? That
hes going to be pelted with verbal rocks, treated in a way different than
in some American cities where nobody questions what a cardinal says. Here
theres a lot of give and take, said Koch. You have to be
willing to stand up and give a lot in terms of admonitions and compassion, to
extend the hand of friendship to people you disagree with. What a great
city!
What Koch was saying is that in New York, if you give it,
youve also got to be able to take it.
National Catholic Reporter, May 29,
1998
|